Book Review: A Gentleman Never Keeps Score (The Sedgwicks #2) by Cat Sebastian

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Title: A Gentleman Never Keeps Score
Series: The Sedgwicks #2
Author: Cat Sebastian
Genre: Historical Romance
Edition/Pages: Mass Market Paperback, 310 pages
Goodreads page


Hartley has become a recluse after his dark secrets were discovered and society shunned him. All of his servants have left and he is alone in the big house where is past haunts him. When Sam shows up at his door looking for a painting of his friend, the two team up to track down and destroy the revealing works. But more than the painting draw the two together, and soon their hearts and lives are entwined. 


➸ POV: 3rd Person from Harley & Sam’s POVs

➸ Hartley Sedgwick: 23, White, Shunned from society, Recluse, Middle brother (Ben & Will), Struggling to cope with past trauma

➸ Sam Fox: Black, Retired boxer, Protective, Owns a bar where he helps members of the community, Younger brother

Content Warnings: Sexual assault of a minor, PTSD, Racism & Police Brutality, Homophobia, Theft, Fighting

My Thoughts

While I enjoyed this sequel in the Sedgwick brother series, I didn’t love it the way I did book 1. This book had a far more serious tone than the previous book and packed a lot of difficult themes and commentary into a historical romance.

One of the things I love most about this series is how it tackles topics not normally discussed in this genre. This book had some really heavy themes! Not only did this continue to explore what it meant to be queer in a time where that was unacceptable, but it also explored race and trauma. I can’t speak to the accuracy of any of representation (I will be searching for some own voices reviews on this), but I appreciate it being explored in this predominately straight/white genre (Just a note – this book is not own voices, so that is something to be aware of)

I love Cat Sebastian’s writing and I’m always swept away by her books. However the characters in here weren’t quite as captivating as the previous book. I loved Sam! He was so protective and caring for everyone around him – I just wanted to wrap him up and protect him. But I didn’t connect to Hartely at all… I can’t quite place my finger on what kept me from connecting with his character, but he felt flat for the entire book. Because of that, I never fully believed in the romantic relationship. I saw and understood their physical attraction, but never quite bought into it developing beyond that.

Overall, this sequel was good, but not my favorite of the series. I did love the ending and absolutely cannot wait for Will’s book!


One thought on “Book Review: A Gentleman Never Keeps Score (The Sedgwicks #2) by Cat Sebastian

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s